Christianity Explained Information

Find Christian Unity in Biblical Explanations of the Doctrines That Count!

You're Invited

You have a choice to make: You can either believe the opinions of theologians, atheists, or agnostics, or you can determine for yourself what the Bible says by studying it.

If you do nothing else, be sure to read thIs --------------------------->

[For more information, click on any underlined text.]

What difference does it make?

Topics

What Is Christianity Explained Information?

What Is Religion and Where Did It Originate?

Who or What Is God?

What Is Christianity?

What Is the Bible, and How Relative Is It to My Life?

Can I Understand the Bible?

What Are Messianic Prophecies?

Who Was Jesus of Nazareth, Really?

Why Are There So Many World Religions?

Why Are There So Many Christian Denominations?

What Is the Law and How Does It Apply to Me?

The Ten Commandments

What's All This About the End of the World and End-time Prophecies?

Isn't the Book of Daniel a Closed Book?

Revelation: How can anyone understand all that symbolism?

How Do I Identify a Cult?

Who or What Was Jesus' Mother, Mary?

Why Are We Here?

Where Do We Go When We Die?

Didn't Darwin Disprove Creation?

What's the Truth About Faith and Works?

Christian E-mails: the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

Complete Directory of Articles/Studies

Title Abbreviations for Books of the Bible

Genesis - Ge
Exodus - Ex
Leviticus - Le
Numbers - Nu
Deuteronomy - De
Joshua - Jos
Judges - Jud
Ruth - Ru
I Samuel - 1sa
II Samuel - 2sa
I Kings - 1ki
II Kings - 2ki
I Chronicles - 1ch
II Chronicles - 2ch
Ezra - Ezr
Nehemiah - Ne
Esther - Es
Job - Job
Psalm - Ps
Proverbs - Pr
Ecclesiastes - Ec
Song of Solomon - So
Isaiah - Isa
Jeremiah - Jer
Lamentations - La
Ezekiel - Eze
Daniel - Da
Hosea - Ho
Joel - Joe
Amos - Am
Obadiah - Ob
Johah - Jon
Micah - Mic
Nahum - Na
Habakuk - Hab
Zephaniah - Zep
Haggai - Hag
Zechariah - Zec
Malachi - Mal
Matthew - Mt
Mark - Mr
Luke - Lu
John - Joh
Acts - Ac
Romans - Ro
I Corinthians - 1co
II Corinthians - 2co
Galatians - Ga
Ephesians - Eph
Philippians - Php
Colossians - Col
I Thessalonians - 1th
II Thessalonians - 2th
I Timothy - 1ti
II Timothy - 2ti
Titus - Tit
Philemon - Phm
Hebrews - Heb
James - Jas
I Peter - 1pe
II Peter - 2pe
I John - 1jo
II John - 2jo
III John - 3jo
Jude - Jude
Revelation - Re

Was Jonah Really in a Whale's Belly for Three Days?

This is another of those cases where, if you had the right resources and the initiative (read: if you really cared), you could get this from just a tiny bit of research.

The short answer is, "No."

The longer explanation begins with the verse itself:

Jon 1:17 Now the Lord had prepared a great fish to swallow Jonah. And Jonah was in the belly of the fish three days and three nights.

Does anyone see the word whale there?

No?

Okay; just checking. I didn't see it in any of the versions I have access to either.

But that's not what the "tiny bit of research" is.

Let's look at the word generally translated
swallowed up in the Hebrew:

[lb Bala` (beh'-lah);  Verb, Strong #: 1104

  1. to swallow down, swallow up, engulf, eat up
    1. (Qal)
      1. to swallow down
      2. to swallow up, engulf
    2. (Niphal) to be swallowed up
    3. (Piel)
      1. to swallow
      2. to swallow up, engulf
      3. squandering (fig.)
    4. (Pual) to be swallowed up
    5. (Hithpael) to be ended
KJV Word Usage and Count
swallow ... 34
destroy 9
devour 3
covered 1
at...end 1

Oh, look. The word engulf is part of the possible translations put forth by 2 scholars, and it was translated covered once and that's not even one of the definition choices.

Hmmm.



And now for the word translated belly.

h[m Me`ah (may-aw');  Noun Masculine, Strong #: 4578

  1. internal organs, inward parts, bowels, intestines, belly
    1. inward parts
    2. digestive organs
    3. organs of procreation, womb
    4. place of emotions or distress or love (fig.)
    5. external belly
KJV Word Usage and Count
bowels 27
belly 3
heart 1
womb 1

The first choice under the number one definition, and the second term within the number one definition itself is "inward parts". Yet according to the King James Version Word Usage and Count chart, that definition, fairly prominent in its listing, is NEVER used in scripture. Seems a bit bizarre, doesn't it?

So, here's where faith and logic come together:

Is God capable of preparing a fish in any manner that he might choose for the specific purpose of swallowing-up Jonah?

Don't know about your God, but my God can do anything He likes. He created everything that has life, so if he wants to create a one-eyed one-horned flying purple people eater, He can in my book. He created dinosaurs and hummingbirds; why not a fish that can swallow a man?

And with all the new species being found, why couldn't the unexplored depths of the sea be hiding such a fish or at least the fossils of one?

But beyond my faith, there's the off chance that the translators might have overlooked the "easier to swallow" (pardon the pun) possibility that Jonah was sucked into the mouth of an extremely large fish and rode around in its mouth for three days? If you don't have my faith in God, would that not meet your criteria for believability?

Last, but not least, "Why do people come up with these objections to believing Scripture, anyway?"

My guess?

Maybe because they're too logical and lack the ability to believe in someone as awesome as God. Maybe they think they have all the answers and don't need God. Maybe they like their "sinful" lives, so they don't want to believe in God.

Does it matter?

Only to those who do believe in God and who love them and want to see them in Heaven. Let's see. That would be God and Jesus and the Holy Spirit and the unfallen angels, for starters. So if they think no one cares whether they believe, they're mistaken.

I care, and I don't even know most of them. I just know what the end of this life is and what God's promises are concerning where He wants to lead us. But that's another study.

Related Links

The Presence

Written in the Heart

The Appearing

The Truth About Mary Magdalene

Prophecy Speaks Seminar

Hope Through Prophecy

Prophecy Code

Study by Topic

More Valuable Links

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Scriptures:

Within Text:

Jonah 1:17


 

 

 

 

 

 

Privacy

Disclaimer
Copyright 2005-08 Lynda Karr
You are welcome to bookmark this page or place a link to it from your Web site or E-book; however, nothing on this site may be copied, stored, or reproduced by any means or used in any manner for any purpose unless you
first contact Lynda Karr.
Contact
Lynda